8.31收到预录邮件,9.2号在系统中正式为接受状态

论文地址:

Qiang, Y., Wu, W., Lu, J., Jiang, B., Ziegmann, G. Progressive Molecular Rearrangement and Heat Generation of Amorphous Polyethene Under Sliding Friction: Insight from the United-Atom Molecular Dynamics Simulations. Langmuir the ACS journal of surfaces and colloids 2020.

仓库地址:

10.1021-acs.langmuir.0c01949
注:目前只更新了两轮审稿的response

Langmuir二审

编辑👴:Provisional Accept

We are pleased to inform you that your manuscript has been provisionally accepted for publication in Langmuir, provided that you make the following formatting changes:

In Manuscript:

  1. Authors’ first name and last name can’t be abbreviated. Please contact the author to complete the authors’ name (Gerhard Ziegmann) in the system.
  2. Experimental OR Materials and Methods section is missing.
  3. “Results” and “Discussion” sections should be combined. The main text of the manuscript must be divided into sections. There are Abstract, Introduction, Experimental, Results (with Discussion), Conclusions. Please check and correct the sections.
  4. Journals in references should be well abbreviated.
  5. Full page number is missing in reference 32.

Please submit your revision on your ACS Paragon Plus homepage. When submitting your revised manuscript through ACS Paragon Plus, you will be able to respond to the formatting changes requested above in the text box provided or by attaching a file containing your detailed responses outlining the changes made.

On resubmission, please provide 2 copies of the final manuscript file:

  1. The final revised manuscript file that that does not contain any highlighting or editing marks. This file should be uploaded as the primary manuscript document file.
  2. A marked copy of the revised manuscript that shows changes made on revision clearly highlighted. This file should be uploaded SEPARATELY FROM THE FINAL MANUSCRIPT FILE as Supporting Information for Review.

In addition if you have Supporting Information do not add any highlighting or other editing marks to the Supporting Information file that is intended to be published with the manuscript (this file is uploaded as “supporting information for publication”).

We ask that you submit your revision no later than 13-Sep-2020. If further delays are necessary, please notify us as soon as possible. Please use the link below to access a manuscript checklist for guidance in preparing your revision.

Reviewer1🗣:Publish as is.

Comments:

The authors have carefully considered all the issues raised in the previous round of review, and addressed them satisfactorily. Although there are some grammatical errors, hope these can be corrected during proofreading. Now, I would like to recommend its acceptance.

Additional Questions:

Significance: High (suitable for Langmuir)

Originality: High (suitable for Langmuir)

Broad Interest: High (suitable for Langmuir)

Technical Quality: High (suitable for Langmuir)

Is the manuscript appropriate for Langmuir?: Yes

Are the conclusions adequately supported by the data?: Yes

Are the references appropriate and correct?: Yes

Is the English adequate?: Yes

Is the quality of the figures sufficient?: Yes

Are the data statistically significant with appropriate controls included?: Yes

Reviewer2🗣:Publish as is.

Comments:

The authors have addressed all my questions, and I think this manuscript is now acceptable for publication.

Additional Questions:

Significance: High (suitable for Langmuir)

Originality: Top 5% (suitable for Langmuir)

Broad Interest: High (suitable for Langmuir)

Technical Quality: Top 5% (suitable for Langmuir)

Is the manuscript appropriate for Langmuir?: Yes

Are the conclusions adequately supported by the data?: Yes

Are the references appropriate and correct?: Yes

Is the English adequate?: Yes

Is the quality of the figures sufficient?: Yes

Are the data statistically significant with appropriate controls included?: Yes

更多推荐

投稿历程(8.3-8.31)(Langmuir二审结束)